I have been hit by the economy in regards to my ad revenue. Revenue has dropped, but, not only that, click through rates (CTR) have dropped. Revenue drops I can handle, I understand the economics of the business world, of which advertising is a big part of.
The CTR though, that's another matter. While it can be a truth that in tough times people are clicking less ads because they are not looking to spend money, I can understand that, but, likewise, it is also something that you have some direct impact on.
The money people are willing to spend on ads we as publishers are relatively powerless over. Ihave noticed CPM drops across the board, basically every ad system I use has seen some, oddly, the least effected seems to be
Kontera, the in-test advertising which, ironically, many people say is the most annoying of all ads.
So, in an effort to at least try to do something about CTR, I decided to try a little redesigning. On one of my bigger sites I have always had an AdSense horizontal link unit blended in to the header over the site search engine. I decided to change this with a header redesign. I wanted to lighten up the look of the site a bit as well.
What I did was made the header a bit taller, and move the search engine (a
Google CSE of course) under the logo on the other side of the header, and add some imagery to the header that related to the site. The site is about audio production, so across the header I put the image of a wave form. Then, inside that wave form I blended a 468x60 ad. I have talked with Google previously about this type of designing using design elements like that to wrap around ads, as it may have violated any of their rules, but, they have said that it is OK by their standards. I saved the email from them just in case I get called on it later. :-)
Much to my surprise that ad has jumped in to the top few channels on my site now. Just as well, it doesn't visually take up loads of space on the site since it's part of a section of the site that would be taken up by the header anyway. Plus, it allowed me to get rid of the low performing ad spaces toward the bottom of the page and use that space in a first-fold position.
While my experiment is based around AdSense, the same theories will work with any text-based ad system, and should yield similar results, depending on the quality of the ads that are selected to display within it. In the case I described, I also ended up making that header ad the first AdSense code found in the page code, so in theory, it should not only be a first fold ad, but also get the ads of highest relevancy...therefore even further helping the click through.
There is a fine line to draw on that first fold, however. You do want as many of your pages ads in the first fold as possible, but, you also need to have some usable, readable, page content in that fold too. If a visitor comes and sees nothing but ads, they'll leave. With clever design strategies you might be surprised how you can manipulate that first fold. The most common mistake most newbies make is simply making their header too tall, so many people use half of the first fold for some big, fancy logo and catch phrase, no ad, then put two big rectangles under it that fills up the whole first fold...then they wonder why traffic isn't coming in, or sticking around.
You header should not be over 100 pixels tall or so, and often can house at least one little ad unit of some sort. Then you have a few hundred pixels beneath that for content.